No Exemption Can Be Granted From NEET: Supreme Court

Admission to all medical courses in the country, even those run by minority and private organisations, will be on the basis of National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) scores, the Supreme Court said today. "There is no violation of rights of minority institutions to come under NEET. At present, education is devoid of its real character of charity; it has become a commodity," a three-member bench of Justices Arun Mishra, Vineet Saran and MR Shah said while making it clear that the rights of minority organisations would not be affected by the use of a common entrance test for prospective medical students.

"It is not possible to prescribe further examination over and above NEET that cannot be said to be workable, no exemption can be granted from NEET, considering the objective with which it has been introduced. We find that the uniform Entrance Examination cannot be said to be unreasonable regulatory framework," the court said. 

NEET is conducted by the National Testing Agency or NTA annually and the next edition, according to Human Resource Development Ministry officials, is expected to be conducted in June. Last year, out of the 14,10,755 candidates appeared 7,97,042 qualified for admissions in various medical and allied undergraduates courses in the country.

The court while disposing of a petition by Christian Medical College Vellore Association also said that, "Considering the terms and conditions for affiliation and recognition for professional medical and such other professional courses are binding, and no relaxation can be permitted in the conditions".

Minority institutions had challenged the admission process under NEET, arguing it affected the rights of minority unaided private professional institutions.

They also argued that minority institutions must be allowed to have a separate admission exam - over and above NEET.

The court rejected both views.

"Uniform Entrance Test qualifies the test of proportionality and is reasonable.  The same is intended to check several maladies which crept into medical education, to prevent capitation fee by admitting students which are lower in merit and to prevent exploitation, profiteering, and commercialisation of education," it added. 

"The minority institutions are equally bound to comply with the conditions imposed under the relevant Acts and Regulations to enjoy affiliation and recognition, which apply to all institutions. In case they have to impart education, they are bound to comply with the conditions which are   equally applicable to all.  The regulations are necessary, and they are not divisive or disintegrative," the court said.  

Among the institutions which petitioned included Christian Medical College, Vellore, Manipal University, SRM Medical College Hospital and Karnataka Private Medical and Dental Colleges Association.

It said, "The charitable activity of education became a saleable commodity and prerogative of wealthy persons and poor students were forced to get education funded from Banks making it difficult for them to come out of tentacular octave of interest. They are exploited in bud before they bloom into flower. The ill-reputation developed by MCI forced to change its entire structure...The situation is still grim and require to be dealt with firm hand and steely determination".

It rejected submission of some of the minority institutions, that it was open for them to impose higher standards of merit and said that when it comes to national standards and the objects sought to be achieved by NEET, to conduct individual examinations by some institutions cannot be permitted.

The top court said that there is no doubt that there are certain colleges which have produced doctors of international fame and they are an asset to not only for India but for the entire humanity.

Relying on several apex court judgements including a constitution bench verdict of 2002 in TMA Pai Foundation, the bench said, "Thus, we are of the opinion that rights under Articles 19(1)(g) and 30 read with Articles 25, 26 and 29(1) of the Constitution of India do not come in the way of securing transparency and recognition of merits in the matter of admissions...It is open to imposing reasonable restrictions in the national and public interest".

It said minority institutions are equally bound to comply with conditions imposed under the relevant Acts and Regulations to enjoy affiliation and recognition.

"To weed out evils from the system, which were eating away fairness in admission process, defeating merit and aspiration of the common incumbent with no means, the State has the right to frame regulatory regime for aided/ unaided minority/private institutions as mandated by Directives Principles, Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution," it said.

More News
UPSC CSE Main: Political Science & International Relations most preferred additional subject
The Minister also informed that the majority of the candidates recommended in the Civil Services (Main) exam have been from the engineering stream, which has been a constant trend since 2017, followed by humanities, science and medical science. Poli...
IIT-Kharagpur launches online short-term digital marketing course, invites applications
Classes for the new programme will be conducted from January 15 to January 19, 2024. Candidates will be admitted on a first come first serve basis. The Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Kharagpur has launched an online short-term course on digita...
ICSE Date Sheet 2024: Class 10th exams to begin on Feb 21, Class 12th from Feb 12
ICSE Board Exam Date 2024: The CISCE will announce the Class 10 and Class 12 results in May. ICSE, ISC Board Exam 2024 Date Sheet Released: The Council for the Indian School Certificate Examinations (CISCE), which administers the ICSE Class 10 ...
XAT Registration 2024 Last Date Extended; Apply Soon at xatonline.in
XAT 2024 Registration: Xavier School of Management (XLRI), Jamshedpur has extended the last date to apply for the Xavier Aptitude Test (XAT) until December 10, 2023. Interested candidates must apply on the official website: xatonline.in before the la...
XAT 2024 Registration: Last date to apply for MBA entrance test on xatonline.in
XLRI - Xavier School of Management will close the registration cum application process for the XAT 2024 examination today, November 30. Candidates can apply for the examination on the examination website, xatonline.in. The exam is sc...
CAT 2023 answer key, response sheet released; raise objections by Dec 8
CAT 2023 Answer Key: The final CAT 2023 answer keys will be made available at the official website – iimcat.ac.in after the window to raise grievances get over on December 8. CAT 2023: The Indian Institute of Management Lucknow (IIM Luckn...
NEET: 485 UG, 247 PG medical seats vacant in 2023, Minister tells Rajya Sabha
The NEET PG percentile has been dropped to zero to fill up the vacant seats, and therefore every candidate who appeared in NEET PG becomes eligible to participate in counselling, the government tells Parliament. According to the National Medical Com...
JEE Main 2024: Application correction starts today at jeemain.nta.ac.in
JEE Main 2024: The JEE Main 2024 application correction window will close on December 8. JEE Main 2024: The National Testing Agency (NTA) is set to open the JEE Main 2024 application correction window today, December 6. Candidates who want to m...
VTUEEE Syllabus 2024: Download Detailed Syllabus PDF
VTUEEE Syllabus 2024: Vel Tech University has released the VTUEEE 2024 syllabus for the VTUEEE exam on its official website, Veltech.edu.in. The syllabus mainly incorporates the topics of physics, chemistry, and mathematics of the 11th and 12th ...
VTUEEE Application Form 2024 (Released) - Apply Online @veltech.edu.in
VTUEEE Application Form 2024 - Vel Tech Institute has released the VTUEEE 2024 application form online veltech.edu.in. The direct link to fill out the application form of VTUEEE 2024 is updated on this page. Class 12th passed students and d...